| 
| 
 CONTENTS OF THE JULY  2004 ISSUE Vol.72(2) 
 | 
 
GENERAL ARTICLES Difficultés de calculer les cotes 
des swaps de volatilité Consultation publique sur les 
fusions du secteur financier : une synthèse des réponses des participants 
EVALUATED ARTICLES La structure par terme des taux 
  de défaut et ratings Le risque systémique : revue de la 
littérature COLUMNS 
Current Events Chair's Chronicle Insurance and Risk 
Management Financial Risk Management Actuarial Chronicle Major Risks Technical Study 
L’autorité des marchés financiers 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
LA STRUCTURE PAR TERME DES TAUX DE DÉFAUT ET RATINGS The 
aim of this paper is to describe and compare the rating principles used by the 
main rating agencies (Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s and Fitch) with the benchmark 
scoring developed by the Banque de France. In particular, we analyse the term 
structures of default and rating and the dynamic of transition matrices. 
 
 
 
 
 
 LE RISQUE 
SYSTÉMIQUE : REVUE DE LA LITTÉRATURE Our 
study is interested on systemic risk. The aim is to display theoretical and 
empirical developments dealing with this concept. All over this paper, we 
distinguish between two cases: the banking markets as a first case and the 
payment and settlement system as a second case. Besides, we focus our attention 
on some policies that would be applied in order to prevent from such a risk. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Difficultés de 
calculer les cotes des swaps de volatilité 
Volatility swaps and variance swaps are new derivative products in fashion since 
1998. This paper presents an analytical solution to compute the quotation of a 
volatility swap and examine its limits. This analytical solution was found by 
Javaheri, Wilmott and Haug (2002) and it uses a GARCH (1,1) process to estimate 
the volatility of the returns of the financial instrument studied. We apply this 
procedure to estimate the quotations of volatility swaps of differing maturities 
written on the S&P TSX60 index of the Toronto Stock Exchange. We have written a 
Visual Basic (Excel) program to compute these quotes. A simulation of the model 
revealed that it is very sensible to the estimation of its parameters, 
particularly the speed of adjustment of the instantaneous variance and the 
degree of kurtosis in the distribution of returns. A too small speed of 
adjustment or a too high kurtosis might kill the volatility swap. These results 
being more pronounced for long term swaps, we might question the use of the 
analytical solution to price long term swaps. In view of the recent advent of 
volatility swaps, we hope that our contribution on this subject will help the 
financial analyst to better grasp the computation of a volatility swap quotation. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
CONSULTATION PUBLIQUE SUR LES FUSIONS DU SECTEUR 
FINANCIER : UNE SYNTHÈSE DES RÉPONSES DES PARTICIPANTS This 
paper presents a synthesis of the public response to the consultation initiative 
taken during Fall 2003 by the Federal Government on the subject of mergers 
between large financial institutions. Issues outlined are related to cross 
pillar and large insurance company mergers, public interest determination, 
possible guidelines for the future structure of the financial services sector, 
divestitures, full functionality of ATMs, foreign bank entry, and credit unions. 
Among the contributors are banks, life-insurance companies, credit union 
representatives, consumer interest groups and other independent participants. 
  | 
 | 
 To get an article  | 
| 
 | 
|||
| 
 Last updated: July 2004 
Insurance and Risk Management Journal, revue.assurances@hec.ca © HEC Montréal, 2004 All rights reserved.  | 
HEC Montréal
 Assurances Journal  | 
||